rockcritics.com

there goes everybody

Archive for December, 2007

Question of the Week: Are Your Friends …

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on December 26, 2007

mostly other writers or non-writers? Do they work in related fields or not? Either way, how does it contribute to the ‘frienemy’ notion?

Posted in Question of the Week | 6 Comments »

Almost Infamous – Robert Matheu and the Big Book of Creem, Part I.

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on December 19, 2007

Matheu snaps Hynde through the mirror, darkly.

Robert Matheu is pretty excited about his book release, CREEM: America’s Only Rock ‘N’ Roll Magazine. In fact it’s all he can talk, or e-mail, about. It isn’t a session with one of the hundreds of musicians he’s photographed before. No, this time it’s all about the book he just finished with a little help from some of his old, and new, friends.

Starting out like many of his Creem compatriots, an impressionable young music enthusiast from Michigan, Matheu instead used photos for words, providing the visuals for many an infamous caption. While Creem was known for using many photographers, it was he who remained most affixed to the magazine, later being a guiding force in the 1980s after his move to the West coast. Leafing through back pages (often literally), it can be great fun to try to spot all the photos. This game will be slightly easier with the book.

AR: What was your first introduction to Creem?

RM: In my early teens, growing up on the West side of Detroit – and that was actually the hard part when I was writing the outro to the book – remembering the bookstore at the corner of my street. Thankfully, my brother didn’t do as many drugs as I did over the years and he actually remembered. I didn’t really start reading it until ’71. I had a lot of friends, older friends, but I think of our lot, I was the first to discover Creem. They sold it at the corner store on my street and at that time had an adult section. It was displayed right on the rack next to Al Goldstein’s legendary Screw Magazine because the name had the weird spelling with the double e; it was kind of misconstrued as being some sort of soft core porn magazine.

Richard Siegel, who is what I refer to as on of the founding fathers, actually used that to their advantage in the early days because from what I understand of all the stories I heard from Rick and Charlie Auringer, they pretty much when they got the paper done, when it was still the double-fold newspaper, everyone had had their duties – almost like a paper route – taking it around to different stores that they actually went to.

Creem was like the only one that appealed to our sensibilities because even though Rolling Stone was around it was very much, you know, they wrote about the Jefferson Airplane and Grateful Dead, which wasn’t necessarily the stuff we were seeing in Detroit. It was much more originally a local magazine. I think that’s what Tony Reay meant, when we first hooked up and started talking about the website, he said that was his original vision; we were supposed to be about the local scene. It was such a beautiful time and Detroit was such a different city, but it was like CKLW being what it was and WKNR, it was all about Motown, which is why I could never relate to Rolling Stone.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Creem, Interviews | 3 Comments »

Question of the Week: What Were Your Favorite Magazines …

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on December 18, 2007

while growing up and why? What are some of them now, or what do you miss about former ones?

Posted in Question of the Week | 10 Comments »

EXTRA: Music Criticism Thriving!

Posted by s woods on December 16, 2007

Lately, it seems that many of the pieces that get linked to around here are about how dismal are the prospects of music criticism. The equation regarding criticism that is more than “consumer advocacy” seems to be: readers don’t want to read it, publishers don’t want to publish it, writers thus slouch in their duties to provide it. But are there counter-examples to this mentality and to this assumption? (And if so, where are they?) Anyone out there thinking otherwise?

Posted in Blabbin' | 3 Comments »

Death Becomes Us?

Posted by s woods on December 16, 2007

Clouds and Clocks, the brainchild of Italian correspondent Beppe Colli (and a great site for interviews with well known experimental artists as well as with various music critics) , recently celebrated its fifth year of existence with some interesting thoughts on the health of music criticism, etc. The comment that most caught my eye, of course, was this one:

“To repeat: preconditions don’t look too favourable. Francis Davis still writes lengthy pieces for the Village Voice, but how many writers today have to write, by necessity, ‘pills of wisdom’? And what about those movie reviews of ever-shrinking length where at the end of the piece one gets to see the trailer? Or those reviews of albums by ‘classic’ artists that offer a video off YouTube? And maybe it’s just me, but the moments when the website RockCritics appears to really come alive is when it deals with dead writers or dead magazines.”

That’s a totally fair comment, I think (as proven by our recent coverage of all matters Creem-related), and though we never specifically set out at any point to turn this site into http://www.deadrockcritics.com, things did sort of just evolve a little in that direction. Though not entirely: I/we like (and have covered–and will continue to cover) plenty of living, breathing things as well, but I do think part of our mission around here is to forge a bridge to the past (and keeping things thought to be dead alive, at least in my/our/your/whoever’s imagination).

Now excuse me while I go consult my Ouija Board to find out who our next interview subject should be…

Posted in Blabbin' | 2 Comments »

Bomp! Saving The World One Record At A Time…

Posted by s woods on December 14, 2007

Mark Boudreau in the Rock and Roll Report reviews a brand new Bomp! anthology:

“I can distinctly trace my introduction to rock and roll like it was yesterday. From my first pre-pubescent exposure to a live Beach Boys record in Grade 5 followed quickly thereafter by the hard rock blast of Cold Gin by KISS, what has stuck with me almost as much as the music has been those that have taught me along the way and introduced me to all kinds of amazing rock and roll. From KISS to the Rolling Stones, from Styx to Frank Zappa and from the Sex Pistols to Rush (niche-free even back then!), my desire and interest in not only listening to but reading about rock and roll grew in leaps and bounds.

“As I look back at my musical journey through the rock and roll landscape, three people come to mind as being essential, not only to my enjoyment of rock and roll but to broadening my musical horizons: Keith Richards, Peter Buck and the incomparable Greg Shaw.”

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments »

Beyond and Back: The Punk Turns 30 Exhibit

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on December 12, 2007

Backstage and Beyond

Although the verdict is still out as to whether 2007 was a complete bust, a bright spot was veteran punk rock photojournalist Theresa Kereakes’ celebrating three decades of punk rock’s uppers and downers with her moving art show, Punk Turns 30.

Working the West coast circuit since she was a teen, and later going bicoastal, she amassed a cache of visually explosive iconography, including signature snaps of Darby Crash, Jeffrey Lee Pierce, Patricia Morrison  and bands The Cramps, Dead Boys and Germs, as well as group shots of stars during downtime.

While this past fall provided a gothic backdrop for shows in Oxford, MS and Memphis, TN, this month the traveling photo exhibit, Unguarded Moments: Backstage and Beyond was assembled for Atlanta.

The underground odyssey continues on into the spring with likely stops in New York, New Orleans and Washington, D.C.

Posted in Art & Photography | 1 Comment »

The End of Criticism?

Posted by s woods on December 12, 2007

Steven Rubio has an interesting post up about the Rhapsody music service, its association with Robert Christgau, and the venom (four pages of it) spewed by Rhapsody-subscribing assholes readers about Christgau, and about music criticism in general.

“As you read through the messages, it becomes clear that it’s not just Xgau that the writers hate. They hate the very idea of criticism. Note the problem described above: what gets the writer’s ire is that Christgau dares to give bad reviews to albums the writer liked. Apparently, the sole function of a music writer should be to list the tracks on the album and then get out of the way.

“I think this relates to the growth of artificial intelligence software that predicts our taste preferences. These programs don’t exist to help you appreciate art … they exist to help you find the stuff that already agrees with your tastes. They assume that the listener doesn’t want to be challenged. The rhetoric suggests otherwise, of course … they always claim that their method is the best way to discover ‘new’ music. But by ‘new’ they mean ‘things that are like all the other stuff you already like, only you haven’t heard it yet.’”

I think there’s some truth to all that, but my question is, has it ever really worked differently? Are we talking about a fundamental difference in the reasons people choose to listen to the music they do, or are we simply talking about the means by which they do so? Hasn’t radio been courting like-minded listeners for eons? (And haven’t listeners, in turn, long gravitated to the stations which filled their particular niche?) Ditto music magazines? Ditto live circuits and “scenes”? Have there been more than a handful–if that–of music magazines over the years which have seriously ever challenged their audience’s core assumptions and tastes? I don’t mean these as rhetorical questions–not entirely.

Posted in Blogwatch, Tech & Leisure, Xgau | 11 Comments »

Critical YouTubes: John Façade “Fantôche”

Posted by s woods on December 11, 2007

This French new wave track from 1981 is decent enough, I suppose (they’re no Stinky Toys), but the video’s fantastic for its colourful backdrop, which consists entirely of images from one of my all-time favourite music books (memorably described in a 2004 article by Nick Coleman as “the pornography of rock” as well as its “stained glass window”).

Posted in YouTubes | 2 Comments »

Tribute to Tom Terrell at the Voice

Posted by s woods on December 11, 2007

Gregory Stephen Tate and a dozen others salute Tom Terrell in this week’s Village Voice, a great tribute to a writer and DJ I confess to being barely familiar with before the announcement of his death last week.

“Tom also threw the absolute best D.C. house parties back in the day, affairs eagerly awaited and renowned among men and dogs for their hot fusion of wine, weed, women, and song. Like me, Tom left DJing (and concert production) to scribe in New York: a natural transition, except Tom went on to also do, as he had in D.C., just about every job you could do in the music business without singing, strumming, and dancing. Not just promotion, marketing, and a&r, but tour managing (for Steel Pulse) and rigging lights 50 feet in the air above outdoor stages, too.”

Posted in Obits | Leave a Comment »

Question of the Week: It’s Only Rock and Roll?

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on December 11, 2007

The lyrics have become a saying, or a reaction, to just about any rocker’s (or rock writer’s) super bad behavior. But when does this become a cop out?

Bonus question for this week of weeks: Where were you when John Lennon was unfairly taken from this mortal coil?

Posted in Question of the Week | 2 Comments »

Blog Ketchup

Posted by s woods on December 11, 2007

A few blogs have been on my radar lately:

  • Bart Bull has a blog, entitled Bart Bull, with lots of reprints of his stuff from Spin and Details. Two interesting notes on his sidebar: 1) he claims to have “founded first American xeroxpunk fanzine, Browbeat, in 1977″ (is this true? was it really the first?); and 2) he generously quotes an unnamed Creem writer who once called him, “The only great rock writer to emerge in the ’80s.” 
  • Luc Sante has a blog called Pinakothek, “A blog about pictures. All kinds of pictures.” (“I won’t pretend to specialize or present myself as an expert in anything. Subjectivity is my middle name, a trick memory is my pack mule, and self-contradiction is my trusty old jackknife.”) Also, read this interview with Sante, about his recent (brilliant) collection of essays, Kill All Your Darlings.
  • Speaking of pictures, I can never say too many good things about what may be my favourite blog on the planet, the improbably named, if charlie parker was a gunslinger, there’d be a whole lot of dead copycats. Generally speaking, I’m a word guy, but the photos they unearth here always make me feel like I’ve entered the Land of the Lost, and I say that approvingly. Three recent examples of their excellent-ness (all NY-related): Patti Smith & Leonard Bernstein; Nixon in New York (1963); Valerie Solanis.

Posted in Blogwatch | 1 Comment »

2007 Book Roundup

Posted by s woods on December 10, 2007

By Jon Savage in The Guardian.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a Comment »

Bill Holdship on Creem

Posted by s woods on December 7, 2007

the REAL reason I liked Creem so much in 1974

Awesome piece in Metro Times by Bill Holdship on the Creem debacle, tackling head-on what I alluded to earlier as the underlying 70s-80s battle that seems to be going on between former Creem staffers (I’m of course grateful to be quoted, but that’s not why it’s an awesome piece, really). As the lone commenter notes, Holdship sounds like the first sane inside voice to jump into the fray–the first, anyway, to make a specific, well-thought-out argument that doesn’t sound like mere grudge-bearing (mind you, I gave up scrolling through the reams of pissy comments at the end of the NY Observer articles, as understandable and occasionally entertaining as they are, so maybe I’ve missed something particularly insightful). All of Holdship’s arguments as to why John Cougar Mellencamp (re: Whitall’s earlier quote) was anything but “un-Creem” ring loud and clear to me, and his anecdotes are both priceless and fascinating, i.e., hearing how excited Mellencamp was to read Psychotic Reactions or learning that he invited Richard Riegel to his wedding, so impressed was he with a profile Riegel wrote.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Creem | Leave a Comment »

Get Your Year-End Lists Right Here!

Posted by s woods on December 7, 2007

An insane-in-the-best-way-possible kind of blog list: Largehearted Boy gathers in one place every 2007 year-end music list he can get his hands on–a work in progress, already bustling with activity.

Couldn’t resist taking a peak at Kim Gordon’s ArtForum roundup. Her Britney review… If it wasn’t so bad, you could almost call it art.

Posted in Polls & Lists | Leave a Comment »

Creem’s Wanna-bee Canadian Cousin

Posted by s woods on December 7, 2007

Posted in Zines | 1 Comment »

Two Quick Ones

Posted by s woods on December 3, 2007

1) I’ve received two e-mails recently about the whereabouts of older rockcritics material. It probably doesn’t hurt to reiterate now and again that all the rockcritics material, pre-October 2007, is now archived, via the links on the right sidebar. (To save your mouse the extra centimeter of movement, you can access them right here: interviews, features, index.) I notice that a lot of people are ending up on the front page of the site via old links which are no longer active. Please update your links, where possible. And if you can’t find something that used to be here, let us know.

2) At our last board meeting, we discussed the need to recruit more contributors to this site. Interviewers would be great, of course, but so would people who just want to post links and stuff on this blog. If you’re interested, e-mail myself or A.C. Rhodes. We’d love to hear from you. Don’t be shy.

Posted in Blabbin', rockcritics Archives | Leave a Comment »

R.I.P. Tom Terrell

Posted by s woods on December 3, 2007

The DJ Who Roared: Tom Terrell

In memory of Tom Terrell, July 16, 1950, to November 29, 2007

By Vivien Goldman (in MOLI)

“It is with great sadness–oh, yeah, right, just ignore that regular intro. It is with a big ol’ hole in my soul that I report the passing of writer, photographer, and inspired music aficionado Tom Terrell, a man who was a true soul brother to me and very many others around the whole musical world. He died this morning of prostate cancer…

“Among Tom’s abundant delights were his enthusiasm for and appreciation of the wacky racket of people and events around him–particularly the music. Tom had an encyclopedic knowledge of so many styles: funk, jazz, and rock too. Tommy Tee was a punk rocker who could launch into an insightful analysis of X-Ray Spex just as easily as of go-go king Chuck B & the Soul Searchers or of George Clinton, who hymned Terrell’s soul hometown Washington, DC, as Chocolate City. He was deeply into Brazilian music and Portugese fado–hell, he was a pioneering world citizen of music.” (Full article here…)

(Thanks to Steve Kiviat for sending this. See also Tom Terrell’s article on “Death and Music” from PopMatters in 2006, in part about the death of his aunt, noted jazz pianist/vocalist Shirley Horn.)

Posted in Obits | 3 Comments »

Creem NY Observer follow-up piece

Posted by s woods on December 3, 2007

The New York Observer does a follow-up piece on the Creem debacle, focusing more on Marsh’s, Whitall’s, et al. battles with the ‘zines legacy (and less on the lawsuit).

Seems to me there’s an underlying, more interesting battle going on here–a sideshow to Matheu vs. the Creem critics–that being seventies Creemsters vs. eighties Creemsters (witness Whitall’s comment: “‘John Mellencamp?’ she said with incredulity. ‘He’s in there. Come on! He’s so un-Creem. Also, Duran Duran? I mean, what?’”)

Posted in Creem, Dave Marsh | 3 Comments »

Question of the Week: Lester Bangs; Man, Myth or Mix?

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on December 2, 2007

Music writers, rock mag enthusiasts and musicians alike have revered him, scorned him or thought, “eh.” So, what are your thoughts?

Anyone making jokes about cough syrup mixture will be cyber-spanked, however understandable the temptation.

Posted in Lester, Question of the Week | 27 Comments »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 59 other followers