rockcritics.com

there goes everybody

Archive for November, 2011

How the Drum Machine Changed Pop Music

Posted by s woods on November 21, 2011

Enjoyed William Weir’s perspective on There’s a Riot Goin’ On (in Slate), specifically in regards to how critical the employment of (newly emerging) automated rhythm tracks were to that album’s overall aesthetic.

Groundbreaking though it was, the drum machine’s emergence in the early 1970s didn’t make a lot of waves — largely because listeners didn’t know what they were hearing. To modern ears, these early machines sound crude; it’s hard to believe anyone could mistake them with flesh-and-blood drumming. But as JJ Cale told Mojo magazine: “The deal is, in those days people didn’t know about it, so they didn’t realize what it was.”

Why is every thing ultimately at its most interesting before it becomes a “thing”? (cf. McLuhan’s idea of “effects preceding causes.”)

Posted in Links | 2 Comments »

Best Music Writing, 2011

Posted by s woods on November 21, 2011

The new Da Capo collection, edited by Alex Ross (with Series Editor, Daphne Carr), is out next week. Not sure if this direct link will work, but Amazon lets you take a peak at the table of contents. (Ross, on his blog, points to a couple events in NYC, to celebrate the release.)

Posted in Book (P)reviews | Leave a Comment »

Eddy (and his immortalized dreck!) reviewed

Posted by s woods on November 17, 2011

Rev. Keith A. Gordon in Blurt Online:
“Eddy’s critical flights of fancy notwithstanding, he’s a solid writer of no little wit and humor, and if we readers (such as yours truly) can agree to disagree on some of the dreck that he immortalizes in Rock And Roll Always Forgets, we can all find middle ground. As music critics go, Chuck Eddy has always been a bit of a provocateur, and his tendency to risk ridicule with absurdist or unpopular critical stances is what has always made him an engaging and intelligent writer.”

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Chuck Eddy | Leave a Comment »

More links to Nelson/Avery

Posted by s woods on November 17, 2011

  • Dulani Wallace interviews Kevin Avery at the Vinyl District: “He would only really enjoy writing about things that meant something to him personally, so there are few clues about his own life in many of his pieces. So that became the idea—the first half of the book is the biography, the second half of the book is Paul’s writing. It’s kind of like Paul telling his own story.”
  • Review at The Stash Dauber: “Part of why I find Nelson’s story so disturbingly resonant, I have to admit, is that I see something of myself in him (although he accomplished significantly more and operated on a more highly exalted plain than your humble chronicler o’ events), and something of my father (who spent the last 30 years of his life working on an academic paper that was never completed, let alone published). “

 

[Photo of Paul Nelson by Lawrence White]

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Paul Nelson | 3 Comments »

Wolcott memoir (mostly) raves

Posted by s woods on November 17, 2011

  • Review by A.G. in The Economist: “Every page is a party. Open to any chapter and the capitalised names pop out (Pauline Kael! Robert Christgau! Patti Smith!). Mr Wolcott arrived in New York in 1972 — “just as everything was going to hell” — to work at the Village Voice on the recommendation of Norman Mailer (he had written an article about Mailer for his college newspaper). It was then a city of ‘crappy expectations that didn’t require a trust fund or a six-figure income for the privilege of watching everything fall apart before your eyes.’”
  • Brendan Bernhard, East Village: “If Mr. Wolcott traces the rise and fall of CBGB with the sure hand of a master, he is less convincing when analyzing the intellectual status of his own generation of downtown critics. Willis, Goldstein, and Christgau had ‘the brains, the ambition, the range and grasp to inherit the big desks in the editorial offices and give culture its marching orders,’ but they never did. Well, thank God they didn’t is one’s first reaction, and the second (having read these people) is, ‘Really?’”
  • Michaelangelo Matos in the A.V. Club: “He describes the (Voice) office’s many characters with a warm eye (‘Nat Hentoff… always enjoyed having a First Amendment case to warm his hands over’), but when Kael sweeps him under her wing, the book hits its most romantic pitch. (That, and when he discovers ballet late in the decade.)”
  • “James Wolcott, wise dildo” in the Daily Caller: “This is someone with talent and imagination to burn; sometimes it seems like Wolcott swallowed a Power Verbs book. After experiencing the charge of his prose, it’s almost impossible to go back to the gray stylings of lesser men — the weak Hunter Thompson imitation of Matt Taibbi, the hack righteousness of E.J. Dionne, the convoluted banshee wails of Andrew Sullivan.” (Heh, politicize much, Daily Caller dude?)
  • Choire Sicha sizes the book up at BookForum: “The most interesting subject here is not so much nostalgia — which Wolcott wisely disavows — or the ’70s as a ‘thing,’ but rather the raw human-on-human quality of the day’s critical discourse (as more highfalutin types would later brand it): literary stabbings, accidental slaggings-off, and lingering meannesses as practiced in the small town that is New York. Vain little red-butted monkeys, most of them overzealous typers, but also thinking people: people with an audience and people of an audience.” (“People”? What’s that?)
  • Staying Alive: With A New Memoir On The Shelf, James Wolcott Discusses The Writing Life (New York Observer): “You have to remember that you always write for readers… Most people, their idea of a reader is not even a person, it’s like their expectation of what this piece will do for them… You have to realize that if you don’t make something clear, if you don’t make something interesting, they will abandon it in the second paragraph.”

Posted in Book (P)reviews | Leave a Comment »

Kellow & Kael (+ Schwartz), VII [updated]

Posted by s woods on November 17, 2011

  • Phillip Lopate reviews the bio in Film Comment: “Anyone who has hung around film critic circles will know that narrowing human thinness and provincialism that can set in when there is no other focus but movie talk.”
  • Nick Pinkerton pans the book at Sundance Now blog: “I doubt I would’ve read Kellow’s Kael bio were it not for the fact that I was paid to do so…”
  • Interview with Kellow by Glenn Kenny at Some Came Running: “Her nephew, Bret Wallach, told me that when he was participating in campus demonstrations at Berkeley, she was very much against it. He was stunned because he had always thought of her, I guess, as rebellious Aunt Pauline, constantly giving the finger to the establishment. But she was not in favor of anything that was going to lead you to a point of alienation or isolation. She wanted to be in it. In the vortex, at the vortex.”
  • Jill Krementz covers a celebration of Pauline Kael (Krementz photographed Kael often during the seventies, and many of her photos are featured in Kellow’s book.)
  • Bronx Banter interview with Sanford Schwartz, editor of The Age of Movies: Selected Writings of Pauline Kael: “Kael made reading movie reviews a more intimate and personal experience than it had ever been before. Little criticism of any kind conveyed a comparable sense of there being such a powerful, funny, opinionated, scarily shrewd, and common sensical voice there, talking to you. You wanted to know what she thought about everything. You don’t feel this with most journalists, whether they are reviewing an art of doing a political column.” (Link also includes a number of PK quotes from various interviews and some cool scans.)
  • Reflections on Pauline Kael, by Steve Vineberg (Critics at Large): “Kellow’s misreading gets in the way when he tries to psychoanalyze Kael through her reviews — a temptation that probably no biographer of a writer could resist, but perhaps particularly misguided in this case, since Kael was so nakedly autobiographical in her writing. (It’s unlikely that anyone who confesses that she saw Vittorio De Sica’s devastating Shoeshine after a terrible, unresolvable quarrel with her boyfriend needs to have her judgments examined for hidden motives.)”

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Kael | 1 Comment »

Janitorial duties…

Posted by s woods on November 16, 2011

will resume shortly.

Posted in Blabbin' | Leave a Comment »

“Sophisticated folk-rock”

Posted by s woods on November 4, 2011

March 4, 1967

Posted in Archival | 1 Comment »

Brain Salad Surgery

Posted by s woods on November 4, 2011

Richard Meltzer, Deborah Frost, Patti Smith, David Johansen, and Cindy Lee Berryhill all make an appearance in this weirdly critic-heavy edition of Billboard‘s Album Reviews section, May 1994.

Posted in Archival | 1 Comment »

The Seger Connection

Posted by s woods on November 3, 2011

Randall Roberts (Los Angeles Times) reviews RARAF:

Eddy’s work is compiled in Rock and Roll Always Forgets: A Quarter Century of Music Criticism, a career overview whose very title is contrarian: The writer’s got a problem with the premise of Bob Seger’s hit song “Rock and Roll Never Forgets.” He offers evidence with the lost artists, one-hit wonders, egocentric blowhards and various inspired eccentrics that he’s championed since writing early-1980s pieces on a budding genre called “rhymed funk,” soon dubbed rap music.

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Chuck Eddy | Leave a Comment »

Mental Image of the Day

Posted by s woods on November 3, 2011

From NYT review of Lucking Out:

Wolcott was fortunate to be at The Voice when Robert Christgau was busy creating the best pop music section in the country. We hear about Christgau’s sonic-boom breakup with Ellen Willis and his penchant for conducting some editing sessions at home, in his underwear.

Posted in Book (P)reviews | Leave a Comment »

Love Goes to Buildings on Fire (new book alert)

Posted by s woods on November 3, 2011

Like I don’t have enough books on my plate to finish reading already… Extremely interested in reading Will Hermes’s Love Goes to Buildings on Fire, described thusly:

Punk rock and hip-hop. Disco and salsa. The loft jazz scene and the downtown composers known as Minimalists. In the mid-1970s, New York City was a laboratory where all the major styles of modern music were reinvented—all at once, from one block to the next, by musicians who knew, admired, and borrowed from one another. Crime was everywhere, the government was broke, and the city’s infrastructure was collapsing. But rent was cheap, and the possibilities for musical exploration were limitless.

Jim Farber at NY Daily News posts an early review.

Posted in Book (P)reviews | Leave a Comment »

“Immense amount of collective guilt”

Posted by s woods on November 3, 2011

Kevin Avery on the process of compiling interviews for his Paul Nelson bio/compilation.

It snowballed. One person would lead me to two others who would lead me to four others. A lot of this was accomplished by good will, old friends of Paul’s who really wanted to see his work in print again. I found that among Paul’s friends there was the most immense amount of collective guilt that I’ve ever encountered. They felt like, as a whole, they had let him slip away. Paul didn’t make it easy. A lot of them did try to call Paul and he didn’t return their calls. Paul was very good at shutting doors in his life and not turning back.

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Interviews, Paul Nelson | 1 Comment »

Marcus interviews roundup

Posted by s woods on November 2, 2011

Re: The Doors: A Lifetime of Listening to Five Mean Years:

This is now the third book I’ve written in a month — literally, to the day… I do all the listening, all the interviews, all the reading and all the writing in a month. I don’t know that it is a way to write any given book, but this one on the Doors was easy to write, enormous fun. I just barreled through it.” (John Fleming, TampaBay.com)

Well, I guess the difference is that I made a more emotional connection with Rod Stewart’s songs, or they made a connection with me. It’s just different from the connections I’ve made with the Doors’ music. I love their music in different ways. With ‘Maggie May’ and particularly ‘Every Picture Tells a Story,’ ‘Reason to Believe,’ so many other songs, my chest is open, my heart is beating. Everything is exposed. That’s the way I want to live. It just seems like this incredible vision of a good life, a life of complete fulfillment. That’s what I hear in Rod Stewart, in the stuff that I love the best. There’s no question that what’s going on in the Doors is chillier. It’s more thought-out, more formally experimental — it’s different. I love them both, but in a real different way.” (Michaelangelo Matos, eMusic)

Here I am writing about a band that only existed for a very few years in the late ’60s, and I wanted to make this book about the music — not about the late ’60s… I wanted to take that music out of its context and put it in a new context, which is the present moment.” (Sam Whiting, SF Gate)

Greil Marcus listens to the Doors: On Point with Tom Ashbrook (MP3 podcast)

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Greil Marcus | Leave a Comment »

Sorry, dude…

Posted by s woods on November 2, 2011

Posted in Kael, Tweets | Leave a Comment »

Weather Report, Angry Samoans, Richard “Dimples” Fields, et al.

Posted by s woods on November 2, 2011

December 19, 1981

Posted in Archival | Leave a Comment »

“Catchy rhythm”

Posted by s woods on November 2, 2011

July 30, 1955

Posted in Archival | Leave a Comment »

“Talent”

Posted by s woods on November 2, 2011

August 7, 1954

Posted in Archival | Leave a Comment »

Kellow & Kael VI

Posted by s woods on November 2, 2011

I know, I said I was done with all this, but there’s just too much good stuff to ignore (someone could compile a book of interesting reviews about this book)*. I strongly recommend reading all of these, they are not perfunctory.

* my own mail order copy of which has yet to arrive btw.

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Kael | Leave a Comment »

Classic Music Mag Covers #4

Posted by s woods on November 1, 2011

Melody Maker, January 1974

Posted in Classic Music Mag Covers | 1 Comment »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 59 other followers