rockcritics.com

there goes everybody

Archive for the ‘Creem’ Category

America’s Only…

Critical Collage: Rush vs. the Critics

Posted by s woods on March 5, 2013

A by no means comprehensive or conclusive survey of a Canadian power trio who once upon a time (much less so now) got under the skins of more rock critics than any other rock or pop artist going.

- – - - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - -

rush-creem3
- Creem, June 1981

“For the record, those three are drummer Neil Peart, who writes all the band’s lyrics and takes fewer solos than might be expected; guitarist Alex Lifeson, whose mile-a-minute buzzing is more numbing than exciting; and bassist, keyboardist and singer Geddy Lee, whose amazingly high-pitched wailing often sounds like Mr. Bill singing heavy metal. If only Mr. Sluggo had been on hand to give these guys a couple good whacks…”
- Steve Pond, review of Rush live in Los Angeles, Rolling Stone, 1980

Geddy Lee’s high-register vocal style has always been a signature of the band – and sometimes a focal point for criticism, especially during the early years of Rush’s career when Lee’s vocals were high-pitched, with a strong likeness to other singers like Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin. A review in the New York Times opined that Lee’s voice ‘suggests a munchkin giving a sermon.’ Although his voice has softened over the years, it is often described as a ‘wail.’ His instrumental abilities, on the other hand, are rarely criticized.
- Wikipedia entry on Rush

rush-rs-guide
- Mark Coleman and Ernesto Lechner, The New Rolling Stone Album Guide, 2004

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Archival, Canada, Chuck Eddy, Classic Music Mag Covers, Creem, Critical Collage, Dear Ed., History of Rock Criticism, Links, PDFs and Scans, Quotes, Rockism, Rolling Stone | 3 Comments »

Nina Hagen vs. Journey

Posted by s woods on February 19, 2013

But I hedged my bet right from the beginning too, and kept my day job at the welfare department all the way through, as I was a family man and it provided regular income and medical coverage, etc. That job also gave me another kind of coverage, as a rock critic, as since my writing didn’t furnish my primary income, I could be very choosy who I wrote about. When Creem offered me (among many others) Journey’s management’s junket-to-San-Fran to featureize Steve Perry & co., I could stop believin’ right away and say “NO!” It was fine with me if Journey got written up in Creem, but I didn’t want my byline on the piece. I reserved that for say, a $5. Rock-a-Rama (capsule review) of Nina Hagen, one of my heroine-addictions of the time.

- Richard Riegel, Where Did (My) Zeitgeist Go?

I’d never seen this piece before (it’s from the blogger’s section of Rock’s Backpages) — rockcritics‘ fave rave, Richard Riegel, just having devoured Chuck Eddy’s latest critical tome, reflects on his own career/half-career in music criticism.

Nina Hagen

Posted in Chuck Eddy, Creem, Economics, Links, Quotes | Leave a Comment »

Disco Bubblegum

Posted by s woods on January 31, 2013

“There are many substantial reasons for linking disco with bubblegum; the comparisons, endless. Like [Kasenetz and Katz]‘s clapping sound, Euro- and pop-disco are essentially mediums for a producer’s special sound, whereas the performer’s role remains secondary. Disco combines a constant beat with simple lyrics; like bubblegum’s skip-a-rope dynamics, its function is strictly to provide rhythms for people entangles in the exercise of dance. Furthermore, many disco bands are merely media-crafted vehicles for a producer’s concept. Aren’t Jacques Morali’s Village People just a chic model of K-K’s 1910 Fruitgum Co.?”
- Robot A. Hull, “Yummy, Yummy, Chewy Chewy: A Bubblegum Yarn,” Creem, October 1979

Posted in Archival, Creem, Disco, Pop Musik | Leave a Comment »

Creem Magazine Review (YouTube)

Posted by s woods on January 30, 2013

Less a review, than a tribute, but not bad (there’s no info I can see about who made the thing). There are a couple minor factual quibbles, and it’s a little odd that he quotes stuff from Christgau and Marsh that have no connection to Creem. But a couple lines in it made me laugh (“these were some dead honest, music-lovin’ motherfuckers”), and I learned something new (something I probably should have known but didn’t): the Creem Profiles section was actually a pisstake on Dewar’s scotch.

ola_hudson_dewars_profile

Posted in Advertising, Creem, YouTubes | Leave a Comment »

Carola Dibbell on Fiction and Music Writing

Posted by s woods on January 23, 2013

An interview with Carola Dibbell at Black Clock:

BLACK CLOCK: You wrote rock criticism on and off for thirty years and have spoken before about the leakage between fiction and music writing. Can you explain what you mean by that? What role has music played in your fiction?

CAROLA DIBBELL: In the early seventies, I was surprised and impressed by the rock writing in Dave Marsh’s and Lester Bangs’ Creem, and a little later in the Village Voice music section, edited by Robert Christgau, my husband. In this fledgling and disreputable form, you could be vulgar, personal, amateurish and formally ambitious all at once and actually be read. It gave me a chance to do things with the voice and tone and disorder I was already exploring in fiction that was not actually read. It took longer for me to bring those rock critic elements into my fiction except, I suppose, that writing about pop led me to contemplate genre fiction. Then, in the late nineties, when my fiction was going nowhere, I made a conscious decision to let the rock critic write the fiction, sort of, and the fiction changed a lot.

Posted in Creem, Dave Marsh, Interviews, Lester, Village Voice, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

Susan Whitall interview

Posted by s woods on October 3, 2011

At Music Monday, the first of a two-part interview with Susan Whitall, former Creemster and current author of Fever, a biography of Little Willie John. Keep your eye out for part two, apparently a week from now.

Growing up in the ’60s, music was really revolutionizing society, and vice versa…to be a kid and immersed in it to such an extent that the latest Beatles or Temptations album mean standing in line for hours outside a record store, there was an intensity there that I think may not exist today. Having said that, if there had been a hip, exciting magazine about film in Detroit, or books… I may have drifted there. But in the ’60s music was the top form of expression, so to have a magazine about music in almost my back yard, was too tempting. Really, Creem was more than a music magazine too, we had stories of cultural interest, on movies, books etc. There really were few limits, as long as it was entertaining, so it was a great laboratory of writing.

Posted in Creem, Interviews | 1 Comment »

Preview of Nu-Creem

Posted by s woods on August 11, 2011

What in god’s name has happened to “America’s Only…”??


Posted in Creem, YouTubes | 3 Comments »

More on Nu-Creem

Posted by s woods on July 28, 2011

Rock Chronicle Inspires Battle Over Its Legacy, by James C. McKinley Jr., NYT.

For five years, Mr. Matheu said, he struggled to get Creem off the ground again. He started an online edition, hired freelance writers and assembled an archive of back issues. But the enterprise never made a profit. “We were doing all of it without any advertising support,” Mr. Matheu said. “I continued to do it because I wanted to keep the brand alive.”

I keep going back to the same question, though: why? And who cares? I don’t mean that rhetorically or snidely — I sincerely am asking, “Who cares about seeing a newsstand replica of something which was great 35 years ago?” (And the tenor of which is over-covered currently on something called the internet.) I know it must sound crazy, maybe, what I’m saying here, suggesting that the world doesn’t need another music magazine, especially given just how few there currently are to choose from out there, but — yes, that is what I’m saying. Truth is, I’m as excited about Nu-Creem as I was about the Stooges reunion that happened several years ago, i.e., not at all (though at least with the latter, the right people were involved and presumably getting paid for their efforts; I don’t at all begrudge Iggy and his cohorts from reaping in the rewards denied them in their heyday, I just don’t personally find it that interesting). On the other hand, all this Nu-Creem talk is content for me to cover here; it gives me something to harp on about every couple weeks. I’m not unaware of that contradiction, trust me.

Posted in Creem | 5 Comments »

Creem: “Not so fast…”

Posted by s woods on July 15, 2011

Veteran Creemster Susan Whitall says “Reports of Creem print revival may be premature.”

Posted in Creem | Leave a Comment »

Nu-Creem: D.O.A.?

Posted by s woods on July 15, 2011

Will Jilted Filmmakers Hinder Re-Launch of Fabled Creem Magazine? (via Anthony Kaufman’s ReelPolitik)

“Turns out the man behind the new Creem, with a planned circulation of 150,000-200,000 and a broader music network, including mobile apps and streaming videos, is Jason Turner, a much reviled figure in the indie film world.

As reported in indieWIRE in 2008, Turner was once the head of a company called Mediastile Inc, which repeatedly failed to send royalty payments and traffic reports to Sundance Film Festival shorts filmmakers who screened their films online via iTunes, Netflix and XBox LIVE. One filmmaker, after repeated delays in getting paid, told indieWIRE, ‘My opinion was first that they were incompetent and now that they’re crooked.’”

Update: More on Turner in the NYT comments box.

Everything about this revival smells terrible (worse than the book put out a few years ago, and that was pretty bad). Someone please just put old, original Creem on DVD-ROM and let’s be done with it, okay?

Posted in Creem | Leave a Comment »

Creem Aims for Comeback

Posted by s woods on July 12, 2011

Creem aims for comeback: Sardonic rock mag plans return to print (Jeff Karoub, AP/CP)

“‘We just feel the timing is now,’ said Jason Turner, board chairman of Creem Enterprises Inc. ‘There’s so much amazing music happening today but there’s no filter, no curation happening. We think Creem is a great brand to do this under.’”

My two cents.

Posted in Creem, Zines | Leave a Comment »

Back to School Days

Posted by s woods on July 7, 2011

The first genuine attempt at creating a forum for a dialog between rock writer and rock fan was Paul Williams’ Crawdaddy. The photocopied pages of that magazine carried analysis and interpretation of the importance of rock n roll in articles that were insightful, ridiculous, passionate, literate, embarrassing, brilliant and moronic, often within the span of the same paragraph. Crawdaddy proved there was an interest in such things as serious criticism of contemporary music, a condition that allowed a young Barry Kramer to create what to this day is the only magazine that could lay legitimate claim of “America’s Only Rock ‘n’ Roll Magazine.” That, of course, was Creem.

Some missteps in this piece about the early years of rock criticism, but what the hell, it’s a quick and interesting read, and it contains a few priceless photos.

Posted in Creem, History of Rock Criticism | 1 Comment »

More Creem Chatter

Posted by s woods on April 14, 2008

I-94 Bar, a ‘zine from Australia, devotes its latest issue to “America’s Only…” Includes an interview with Robert Matheu, and reviews of the book.

Posted in Creem | Leave a Comment »

Fun Facts About Dave DiMartino

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on March 27, 2008

 
 

  • Musical heartbreak came early for Dave as his first record, Alvin & the Chipmunks, was left too close to the radiator rendering it unplayable.
  • The first record bought with Dave’s own money was the Beach Boys, All Summer Long.
  • Dave’s father, at the time a record storeowner, originated the policy of renting customers listening devices to call in to hear new music. Somewhat the song man himself, he composed music to which his wife wrote lyrics, making the two a sort of post-war Sonny & Cher.
  • Dave’s high school band, the Intergalactic Space Force, was featured in the title sequence (and participated in the discussion) of Right On, a film paid for by the Dade County School Board and shown to Miami’s teachers for five years in the early ‘70s. It was intended to show what “today’s kids felt about the issues.”
  • Dave and his young teenaged friends often depended on the kindness of strangers to catch rides to regional rock fests. One, held closer to his house at Gulfstream Race Track in ’68, was a dry run for Woodstock.
  • What could be cooler than the Velvet Underground playing a converted bowling ally; perhaps Dave’s attendance? His brother saw them the one night he failed to go to the club. Both, however, witnessed the infamous Doors concert where Jim Morrison was said to have whipped out his member.
  • The following year it would be Dave’s turn to whip it out, as with no portals in the area, he had to make due with the mud – camouflaged by the crowd. He had an awesome view of the Stones, though. Fittingly, they did “Gimme Shelter.”
  • Dave’s fateful introduction to future co-editor Bill Holdship occurred at the record store, Schoolkids, where Dave worked. Bill came up to counter with two records, Andrew Gold’s first and Neil Sedaka’s comeback on Rocket Records. Sadly, he was not being facetious.
  • In a demonstration of passive-aggression over waiting an hour to interview Morrissey,  Dave showed up with his half-eaten McDonald’s dinner. Ironically, this was during the Meat Is Murder tour.
  • Along the same lines, after Dave’s landmark Clash interview (the first time Joe Strummer would destroy a tape recorder), readers gave him flack, too, but mostly for what they projected to be his attitude and chain smoking.
  • During the bouquet-tossing portion of Dave’s wedding reception, a young girl knocked it out of the hands of the woman who caught it. The woman was Bebe Buell.
  • He loves “Roxanne” (the song, silly).
  • Posted in Creem, Interviews | Leave a Comment »

    The Bink Generation: Dave DiMartino In Conversation, Pt. IV

    Posted by A.C. Rhodes on March 27, 2008

    Dave DiMartino, Tristram Lozaw and Mike Lipton

    AR: You’re going on to David Lee Roth now, aren’t you?

    DD: David Lee Roth is a different scenario. It’s hard to put into perspective now, because it doesn’t make much sense – it depends on how old you are. But when Van Halen came out they were really deemed horrendous by most critics. They were excessive, crappy, noisy, and this really sounds like I’m being a jerk, but I had just done a cover story on them – it’s up on Rock’s BackPages. It got reprinted a lot – the first big Van Halen story we did for Creem. The gist of the story – which is embarrassing now, because as a rule I usually hate most heavy metal – was that I confessed I loved and was captivated by Van Halen. And this was circa the Women and Children First record. And I know at that time it was not deemed a particularly hip move to admit you liked Van Halen, I know. I remember I went to this punk club in Detroit to watch Rachel Sweet play and was wearing a Van Halen t-shirt and got scoffed at by many a punk. Roth was a great showman; great sense of humor and everyone in the band were great guys. The music still stands up – this is pre-Sammy Hagar. They existed in an interesting place – this sounds kind of dopey – a sort of pre-post ironic age. They were really good at acting like morons and knowing they were acting like morons and people liking them whether they were or not.

    In a way I was reminded of that years later, living out here, I had to review the new Blue Oyster Cult for Mojo – and this was well past their shelf date, but from an assignment standpoint they asked me who was in town and I said Blue Oyster Cult and they said “Oh, why don’t you review that?” So I saw them and it made me think that BOC also had it good because they had all the trappings of heavy metal, but it all seemed to be a big joke, so they could in one fell swoop get all the hipsters who were sort of in on it, so to speak, and get the ones who weren’t, who liked the music at the same time. And it was just miraculous music that still sounds good.

    AR: I guess by the mid ’80s onward it was like one had to work just to avoid the overexposed acts.

    DD: Yeah, I agree. The other thing you have to think about is how many music videos you’re familiar with – how many stills from those acts you’ve seen in your mind’s eye, how many brain cells have been wasted with their image splattered on them, that sort of thing. They’re all filled with very striking looking people and it’s almost a mathematical process. People that meet a certain visual criteria, who make music that satisfies a certain amount of people in the country – just put them in the machine and this is the result: In the late ‘80s they’d get on every magazine cover, they were all over TV and the same place at the same time. It’s was the complete antithesis of let’s say, Led Zeppelin, who shunned interviews. These others were out there and setting records for just how out there they could be, for how long. I don’t mean out there crazy, but out there in your face.

    Read the rest of this entry »

    Posted in Creem, Interviews | 1 Comment »

    The Bink Generation: Dave DiMartino In Conversation, Pt. III

    Posted by A.C. Rhodes on March 19, 2008

    AR: What was the music scene like in Michigan at the time?

    DD: Well, I moved there in the fall of ‘71. In Miami, I had seen and we were very aware of the MC5 and to a lesser extent the Stooges. Ted Nugent was very bog in Miami in the late ‘60s because of his Amboy Dukes thing, “Journey To The Center of The Mind.” And there were a few Detroit bands I was mildly interested in, like SRC, for example, the Frost, and even Bob Seger, whose “Ramblin’ Gamblin’ Man” had been a hit in Miami as well. But it was very much of a prime music scene, and when I moved there, the most significant aspects of it were already on the decline.

    AR: I see.

    DD: Actually, one of my favorite moments occurred when I on the air, doing my teenage radio show – at the time I must have been 18 at most.

    AR: Do tell…

    DD: I was in the studio of WBRS, one of MSU’s campus stations, doing my “show.” No one else was in there but me, and all of a sudden three or four people come in and introduce me to the main man, John Sinclair, who apparently had just got out of jail for his pot smoking offense or whatever. I really only had any inkling of who John Sinclair was on the basis of his involvement on the first MC5 album, and I heard John Lennon had some sort of benefit or other for him. I guess if you were a hip counter-cultural teen dude from Michigan, this would be an exciting moment for you. So he asked if I wanted to interview him on the air, and what was I going to say, “Nah, see you later?” So – and I still have a tape of this but have never ever played it – we’re talking, and I assume it’s completely obvious…

    Read the rest of this entry »

    Posted in Creem, Interviews | 1 Comment »

    The Bink Generation: Dave DiMartino in Conversation, Part II

    Posted by A.C. Rhodes on March 10, 2008

    DiMartino and Cronkite, circa '71

    DiMartino and Walter Cronkite, circa 1971. (“From a Miami TV show when Walter ‘met the press’ himself – the youth press. I was editor of my high school paper. “)

    - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - -

    AR: What was the scene like in your formative years? What you were listening to and seeing that perhaps influenced what you wrote about?

    DD: I was listening to Soft Machine, Pink Floyd, Quicksilver Messenger Service, Love, Velvet Underground, Nico, Traffic, Van Morrison, Kevin Ayers, The Nice, Captain Beefheart, Frank Zappa, The Incredible String Band, Procol Harem, King Crimson, Tim Buckley – was a big fan then – Todd Rundgren/Nazz, and Humble Pie.

    AR: What else was shaping your young mind, culturally, or sub-culturally at that time?

    DD: I reviewed a lot of that stuff in the paper, back then. I used to spend a lot of time at the record store, where you could by three LPs for $10. Used to buy a lot of records merely because they looked intriguing – stuff like Mandrake Memorial, Mott the Hoople’s first album. I spent time going to the local pop festivals – several in Miami, one in Palm Beach, and saw a lot of live bands; was very focused on the music culture. I played the keyboards, which meant that the high school bands we were in covered music that featured an organ – artists like Vanilla Fudge, Traffic, Iron Butterfly, Blues Image – pretty funny stuff. We were briefly the house band for a college fraternity, which was pretty cool for high school kids. Like I said before, was very interested in music, dopey films that played at drive-ins. As “younger” baby-boomers, we looked at the hippies in San Francisco, the guys in Easy Rider as potential role models. It was an interesting perspective in that they were doing things that we couldn’t quite do yet because we were too young, but aware of all that seemed to be promised. Sex, drugs, and rock hadn’t become a formal cliché yet.

    Read the rest of this entry »

    Posted in Creem, Interviews | 1 Comment »

    The Bink Generation: Dave DiMartino in Conversation, Part I

    Posted by A.C. Rhodes on March 2, 2008

    It could be said that Dave DiMartino has the life many may wish they had – Cameron Crowe included – both in and out of the music business. He was born in an ideal boomer year (1953), in a great locale (New York before moving to Miami), and raised in a music-friendly household that provided the springboard for his creative and career pursuits.While attending Michigan State University, he worked at the school radio station, interviewing the likes of Big Star and Captain Beefheart.

    Soon after he landed squarely at Creem Magazine and almost as swiftly into an editor’s position. He wrote many of the stories about bands, festivals and popular phenomena that linked musical eras; garage and punk to new wave and brit pop of the ‘80s. Since then, DiMartino’s been the most visible guy you’ve never seen.

    Departing just before the office relocated to Los Angeles, he became West Coast bureau chief at Billboard for five years. He then spent the next two as a senior writer at Entertainment Weekly and spent six months as acting West Coast editor for Musician while Bill Flanagan was off writing his U2 book. During that time he wrote Singer-Songwriters: Pop Music’s Performer-Composers from A to Zevon. Dave DiMartino has written liner notes for The Best of Love. To balance the hipness factor, he also did so for Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours. Go ahead, ask him about the Doors. He witnessed their notorious performance in Miami in 1969, he was consultant editor for Chuck Crisafulli’s Moonlight Drive: The Story Behind Every Doors Song, 1967-78 and penned the notes for the band’s The Complete Studio Recordings box set. He was U.S. editor of the 3-volume Music in The 20th Century encyclopedia (M.E. Sharpe, 1998).]

    His job of the past 13 years as executive editor for Yahoo!Music (formerly Launch.com) has taken him to music conferences and studio stages for soundcasts and interviews. In the latter months of 2006 he took time to interview by phone, instant message, and e-mail to share his accounts of growing up with and working for Creem and beyond.

    A.C. Rhodes

    - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - -

    AR: What was your first experience at Creem?

    DD: I was in grad school – I had a B.S. in psychology, but since I was making money writing, I decided to go for a masters in journalism. I did all my course work, so all I had to do was write a thesis, and I had five years to finish it. I got the subject approved, which was a big deal – to compare and contrast artists profiled in Downbeat, the jazz magazine, since its inception, and its coverage of black artists to white versus their historical and sales standing, to see if it was biased, that sort of thing. I was the music writer at the Michigan State paper from ’73 to ’76, but graduated in ’75, so I wrote for another year until someone said, “Why is this guy who doesn’t go to school here anymore writing for us?” I was back the next two years for grad school and was the entertainment editor from ’78 to ’79. I was pretty poor. Then the A&M campus rep told me Creem magazine was looking for an editorial assistant, which I was very happy to hear. I liked Creem and had been reading it since the first nationally distributed issue– the Jackson Five cover in ’71 – so I thought that would be great. I went down to interview with Sue Whitall and Linda Barber. The editorial assistant, Therese Oyler, had taken time off and then quit – and they needed a third hand. So I was happy to get on board.

    AR: And it wasn’t that you were abandoning the idea of grad school since you had some years to finish during the Creem stint.

    DD: I was so happy to possibly work there that I never really spent any time asking simple questions like “How much money do I get?” So I was kind of stunned when I got my first check, because it was so horribly low. But it was okay. It wasn’t that big a deal. My brother-in-law recently told me his father was stunned beyond belief back then. He was a Republican businessman and thought, “Oh, my God – what an idiot my daughter’s boyfriend is.”

    Read the rest of this entry »

    Posted in Creem, Interviews | 12 Comments »

    Old Letters #8

    Posted by s woods on February 8, 2008

    [CREEM, November 1975]

    Posted in Creem, Dear Ed., Xgau | Leave a Comment »

    Former Creemster Bangs On About This, That, the Other Thing

    Posted by s woods on January 24, 2008

    Final installment of Bill Holdship’s Creem history/memoir/book review here, at Metro Times. A much deeper dig than the first installment into the story, the in-fighting, the book, etc.

    A few disagreements along the way, the most major one being in regards to this:

    “Of course, revisionism has been going on for a long time now. In 2000, music critic Simon Reynolds took potshots at Bangs (and me) on his blog, writing that he’d read Bangs’ stuff in CREEM just recently, and while a lot of it was very good, a great deal of it wasn’t all that. But Reynolds obviously couldn’t read it in full context. So that’s sort of like me saying ‘I listened to Elvis in the ’80s,’ or ‘I listened to the Sex Pistols in the ’00s, and I just don’t know what all the outrage was about.’ Take it from someone who was there reading him at the time: Lester Bangs was great, even if it’s harder these days to accept, as Greil Marcus once put it, ‘that the best writer in America could write almost nothing but record reviews.’”

    Read the rest of this entry »

    Posted in Creem, Dave Marsh | 15 Comments »

     
    Follow

    Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

    Join 59 other followers