rockcritics.com

there goes everybody

Archive for the ‘Links’ Category

We look for lively links to give the attention deficit disordered a rest.

Bad Friday Reading #2

Posted by s woods on April 26, 2013

David Bowie once mentioned me in a complimentary way from a stage, in New York City, in the later nineties. This was one of the great unlikely moments of my professional life. It was in the did-I-hallucinate-it category. It was in the did-that-actually-happen category.

- Rick Moody on the new Bowie record. It gets worse — about 6,000 words or so worse. Good luck.

Posted in Links | 5 Comments »

Weekend Read: Barry Manilow

Posted by s woods on March 22, 2013

I was a kid. I cared about volume. And the tears that flowed as (in Band) we went for the crescendo. From the radio I wanted to hear the big chords, the big drums, the big horns. I didn’t know there was a such a thing as being manipulated by the right pauses — I liked Clive Davis’ ear and Clive Davis’ work and I didn’t know yet who Clive Davis was. Michael Jackson was a world apart, a king, but my regular high school favorites were Prince and Rick James, and by the time I hit college, aside from Run-DMC, Sade and Luther Vandross, I was about Whitney Houston, who in 1978 was singing backup disco for the Michael Zager Band. This was seven years before Davis would re-apply what he’d learned making hit after hit with Manilow to the woman who would become one of the most loved and bestselling artists of all time. Listen to Manilow ballads, then listen to Houston ballads. Check, as we used to say in hip-hop, the technique. If it wasn’t broke Davis saw little need to fix it. The songs Davis made with Manilow and Houston are the songs I loved. Besides, what other way had I to judge? My mother, after all, had to tell me when I was 13 who Booker T. Jones Jr.’s dad was. I thought like I used to think about all songs when I was young — that every artist’s song was purely autobiographical, and so 100 percent meaningful. And if I categorized at all, it was based on what radio station played what. So I thought Barry was rock ‘n’ roll — and not rock in a “white” frame. Rock in a frame marked “real.”

Danyel Smith on Barry Manilow at NPR’s The Record.

This is a sprawling (overused word, I know) piece that, because I’m so preoccupied with other stuff right now, I haven’t absorbed fully, but it is dynamite, the kind of music-critical piece I tend to fall hardest for, blending as it does the personal, the historical, the contextual, the musical, and, perhaps by inference — it is Barry Manilow, after all — and in the best way possible, I mean — the revisionist.  The sort of piece you can tell the writer has kept stored in her head for 20 years.

 

Posted in Links | Leave a Comment »

Critical Collage: Rush vs. the Critics

Posted by s woods on March 5, 2013

A by no means comprehensive or conclusive survey of a Canadian power trio who once upon a time (much less so now) got under the skins of more rock critics than any other rock or pop artist going.

- – - - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - -

rush-creem3
- Creem, June 1981

“For the record, those three are drummer Neil Peart, who writes all the band’s lyrics and takes fewer solos than might be expected; guitarist Alex Lifeson, whose mile-a-minute buzzing is more numbing than exciting; and bassist, keyboardist and singer Geddy Lee, whose amazingly high-pitched wailing often sounds like Mr. Bill singing heavy metal. If only Mr. Sluggo had been on hand to give these guys a couple good whacks…”
- Steve Pond, review of Rush live in Los Angeles, Rolling Stone, 1980

Geddy Lee’s high-register vocal style has always been a signature of the band – and sometimes a focal point for criticism, especially during the early years of Rush’s career when Lee’s vocals were high-pitched, with a strong likeness to other singers like Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin. A review in the New York Times opined that Lee’s voice ‘suggests a munchkin giving a sermon.’ Although his voice has softened over the years, it is often described as a ‘wail.’ His instrumental abilities, on the other hand, are rarely criticized.
- Wikipedia entry on Rush

rush-rs-guide
- Mark Coleman and Ernesto Lechner, The New Rolling Stone Album Guide, 2004

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Archival, Canada, Chuck Eddy, Classic Music Mag Covers, Creem, Critical Collage, Dear Ed., History of Rock Criticism, Links, PDFs and Scans, Quotes, Rockism, Rolling Stone | 3 Comments »

Kid Rock

Posted by s woods on March 5, 2013

I have been a professional rock critic, more or less, for 15 years, and as such my friends and family naturally assumed I would be “music-training” my son from birth, regaling him with Sonic Youth and Sun Ra and Ghostface Killah from an early age so as to make him The Coolest Baby on the Planet. Not for him, the scourge of Raffi. But I was determined to avoid this, to instead allow him the calm, sane, non-OCD relationship with music I never had, to just play him the Beatles like all parents do and let things progress organically and probably appallingly from there. I looked forward to being surprised (and appalled).

- Kid Rock Is Cool: In defense of the most reviled genre of them all – by Rob Harvilla, Slate
(cf. “Critical Parenting 101“)

Posted in Links, Quotes | Leave a Comment »

Nina Hagen vs. Journey

Posted by s woods on February 19, 2013

But I hedged my bet right from the beginning too, and kept my day job at the welfare department all the way through, as I was a family man and it provided regular income and medical coverage, etc. That job also gave me another kind of coverage, as a rock critic, as since my writing didn’t furnish my primary income, I could be very choosy who I wrote about. When Creem offered me (among many others) Journey’s management’s junket-to-San-Fran to featureize Steve Perry & co., I could stop believin’ right away and say “NO!” It was fine with me if Journey got written up in Creem, but I didn’t want my byline on the piece. I reserved that for say, a $5. Rock-a-Rama (capsule review) of Nina Hagen, one of my heroine-addictions of the time.

- Richard Riegel, Where Did (My) Zeitgeist Go?

I’d never seen this piece before (it’s from the blogger’s section of Rock’s Backpages) — rockcritics‘ fave rave, Richard Riegel, just having devoured Chuck Eddy’s latest critical tome, reflects on his own career/half-career in music criticism.

Nina Hagen

Posted in Chuck Eddy, Creem, Economics, Links, Quotes | Leave a Comment »

Collectoritis

Posted by s woods on February 18, 2013

Rutherford [Chang] has a unique vinyl collection. He only collects the Beatles first pressing of  The White Album.

I met him in Recess gallery where he exhibits his collection.

In this show Chang is creating a record store that stocks only White Albums. But rather than selling the albums, he buys more from anyone willing to part with an original pressing in any condition.

- Rutherford Change – We Buy White Albums at Dust and Grooves

 

Posted in Links | Leave a Comment »

Car Critics vs. Rock Critics

Posted by s woods on February 15, 2013

I will spare myself no embarrassment. Like William Safire, to whom I credit the idea of an annual mea culpa, I will not attempt to save face retroactively. These are not typos, transpositions of numbers or other copy-editing errors (although I had a few of those too). These are errors of substance and judgment. I can be such an idiot sometimes.

- Dan Neal, What I Got Wrong (and Right) in 2012

Link submitted by a new convert to rockcritics.com (they all come around eventually), who adds, “Dan Neil is a treasure. I’m hardly a car buff, but I read his columns religiously. Wouldn’t it be nice to see some music critics do this?”

I don’t know much about cars other than how to drive and play music really loud in them, and I agree, the article’s terrific. I wouldn’t mind seeing more of this in music criticism, too, though I’m not sure what the criteria would be (critiquing a car being somewhat different than critiquing a piece of music; the former is more reliant on objective metrics, no?). Still, it’s a fetching idea.

Does anyone in music criticism do this? Is it a good idea?

Posted in Letters, Links | 2 Comments »

Bryan Ferry Dedicates New Album to Beyoncé & Jay-Z!

Posted by s woods on February 12, 2013

Forget Rick Moody, there needs to be more focus on just how awful Salon itself can be with their music and entertainment coverage in recent years (which I say as someone who greatly enjoys some of their political coverage). One sort of (extremely silly) example of the sort of thing I’m speaking about appeared just moments ago:

HEADLINE
bf-beyonce

WHAT THE SUBJECT OF THE PIECE, BRYAN FERRY, ACTUALLY SAID
bf-beyonce2

Posted in Links | Leave a Comment »

Just Another Moody Monday, continued

Posted by s woods on February 11, 2013

Okay, so I figure this won’t be the venue for soliciting reactions (I have no strong reaction myself, frankly, beyond mouthing what a few others have already said), but here’s a bit of what’s out there:

Maura Johnston:

But this is all part of a nastier trend in writing about music, one that resembles a dying yawp of a certain type of white dude who still believes in Real Rock And Roll and who is genuinely unnerved by the idea of women fashioning pop culture in their own image.

Robert Christgau:

Often seems to me that an unacknowledged subtext of this kind of dispute connects to how seriously and literally the commenter takes romantic love. I don’t know anything about Moody’s personal life and have never wanted to read his fiction, but from what I can gather he makes a great deal of the dysfunctional family. For all her celebrity bubble etc., Swift takes these matters seriously — more than many in the celebrity bubble. This in itself excites Moody’s contempt.

[note: Christgau's words are comments he posted at his Expert Witness page. Might be worth pointing that out, comments being something different than an actual essay, and truthfully, if it were anyone other than someone famous like Christgau, I'd probably think twice about re-posting this.]

The Twitter search “Rick Moody” is currently pulling up a few gems.

And by the way, did you know that Rick Moody interviewed Richard Meltzer in 2012?

Posted in Links, Richard Meltzer | Leave a Comment »

Just Another Moody Monday

Posted by s woods on February 11, 2013

Someone emailed me on the weekend, with a link to Rick Moody’s recently published Salon piece about Taylor Swift, adding, “I’m interested in what others think about him calling out others on their published appreciation for Swift. I’m curious as to what those who read rockcritics think.”

I’m curious, too. Whadd’ya got?

Posted in Links, Pop Musik | Leave a Comment »

Maura Johnston’s Digital ‘Zine

Posted by s woods on February 4, 2013

Interview with Maura Johnston regarding her new online venture, Maura Magazine.

I really wanted to see if this model would work. I’ve been on the Internet for 20 years. I started doing Web stuff in 1994 and I always loved that you could find weird stuff — boutiques interests that people just wanted to put on the Web. And I feel like with the push to constantly grow pageviews and always shoot for the stars or shoot for the 18-34 male demographic that seems like the default of Internet culture, you lose a lot of the stuff that made the Web an interesting place to be and burrow down. In a curious way — not in the, ‘Oh my god, this is so weird — look at this stupid idiot’ kind of way.

Issue list for Maura Magazine. (You can preview articles but, far as I can tell, need an iPhone or iPad to read the entire thing.)

Posted in Economics, Links, Zines | Leave a Comment »

Rod the Bod

Posted by s woods on February 1, 2013

“‘Do Ya Think I’m Sexy?’ still needs modest defenses. Eerily mimicking the feel of the Stones’ ‘Miss You,’ Stewart’s band plays every extant disco signifier: four on the floor drums, locked-down bass, guitar fills too groove-conscious to do anything besides stay out of the way, sax solo. The key, though, is the amazing synth line, lumbering across the track, suggesting a scenario much colder and sleek than the one written by Stewart (noting the synth is one of my earliest memories). This is the second curious thing about ‘Sexy’: it’s a singer-songwriter narrative bedecked in polyester, which, thanks to the synth and rhythm section, intensifies the comedy.”

Alfred Soto on disco-era-and-beyond Rod Stewart. I have some thoughts on this, may try to express them later, but I don’t read Alfred’s piece as a rebuke to the Bangs/Nelson [insert most '70s rock critics] line on Rod. I dig the visors, though.

Paul Nelson and Lester Bangs Rod Stewart

Posted in Lester, Links, Paul Nelson | Leave a Comment »

Critical Collage” M.I.A.

Posted by s woods on January 29, 2013

m.i.a.

An M.I.A. collage I found following the release of 2010′s Maya (more colloquially known as /\/\ /\ Y /). Not as good, mind you, as Rich Juzwiak’s perfect word-collage of the same, the sort of review which, by its very being, resists anthologization (good).

Posted in Art & Photography, Links, Record Reviews | Tagged: , | Leave a Comment »

Juan Rodriguez’s Rock ‘n’ Roll Life

Posted by s woods on January 25, 2013

I can’t say I’m familiar with the writing of Montreal Gazette rock critic, Juan Rodriguez, but the paper is currently giving him more-than-ample space to reflect on his life as a rock writer, for which, in the shrinking-word-count world in which we live in, they should certainly be commended. Juan Rodriguez’s Rock ‘n’ Roll Life is a seven-part series running in the Gazette between now and March. Along with Rodriguez’s essays, the series includes playlists and archived photos. The first instalment was a good read mostly for Rodriguez’s musings on early rock radio, the second goes up sometime today, and the fourth instalment (still a couple weeks away) is titled, “The Critic Must Die”–so there’s more to look forward to.

This recent musing by Rodriguez*, what do you know, contains excellent bits on Sgt. Pepper, plus a great quote from Meltzer:

“A lot of what happened in the ’60s felt very miraculous, like it was coming out of nowhere. You didn’t have ‘rock-surround’ yet. There was no full map, but it was certainly in massive discontinuity (with) what had been encouraged before, in terms of artistic output. It wasn’t even like anyone was making art — it was just an emanation of self, like breathing, sweating.”

* from part 2

Posted in Archival, Canada, Links, Richard Meltzer | Leave a Comment »

Critical Links Galore!

Posted by s woods on January 25, 2013

150 pieces of music writing from 2012 that Michaelangelo Matos particularly liked.

Posted in Links, Polls & Lists | Leave a Comment »

Elton’s Heavy 100

Posted by s woods on January 23, 2013

In February 1974, Creem published Elton John’s “Heavy 100,” his favourite albums of all-time (or rather, an excerpt of that; according to the introduction, his list-in-progress numbered 286). It’s a fascinating list, very rock critic-friendly in many ways, and it’s viewable here.

Creem, Feb 1974

Posted in Links, Polls & Lists | 2 Comments »

Lester-Watch: Infinite Stretch

Posted by s woods on January 23, 2013

Here’s the latest instrumental album from an up & coming producer by the name of Lester Bangs titled Infinite Stretch, i was very impressed after i checked it out, i was really diggin how he flipped the Ronnie Laws record ‘Friends & Strangers’ and added a jazzy hip-hop feel to it…

Posted in Lester, Links | Leave a Comment »

The Critical Economy (correspondence from Richard Riegel)

Posted by s woods on December 7, 2011

Richard Riegel writes:

“I’m really impressed with Jennifer Szalai’s review of a collection of Dwight Macdonald’s criticism, in the December 12 issue of The Nation, the paper version of which I still subscribe to. It’s a good discussion about Macdonald himself, and his concepts of ‘Midcult’ and ‘Masscult,’ but Szalai’s comments about the current state of criticism are even better for our purposes. She’s talking about literary criticism, of course, but a lot of what she says applies to rock criticism & its fade too. I’d been thinking all along that ‘we’ were being hollowed out by the general economic decline, and that’s exactly what Szalai says here, especially in the two paragraphs I’ve excerpted below:

If one were to point out that the wider authority of literary criticism is barely discernible today, one could hardly be accused of courting a controversy or kicking up a fuss. There certainly is a coterie of Americans for whom literature and its criticism is a matter of urgency or livelihood or both, but the notion of the literary critic as a cultural gatekeeper, whose judgments shape tastes and move units, sounds either fanciful or anachronistic, depending on whether you believe that such a creature ever really existed. Our culture is now so big and so varied, the population so diverse and so fragmented, that the very idea of anything or anyone having “wider authority” sounds silly, if not absurd.

The critical landscape has since been denuded of a whole class of reviewers — the professional critics for those many newspapers and magazines that have cut down their books pages or else eliminated them. Optimists have pointed to the proliferation of online reviews as an indication that criticism is flourishing, but the payment for most reviewing these days is meager to nil. When writing a review becomes a diversion instead of a vocation, or else an arena for book authors to horse-trade and log-roll—the literary world’s penurious equivalent of the financial world’s “revolving door” — then reviewing will list toward clubbiness, bitterness or mushy praise. There are clearly some brilliant exceptions, and even a few determined critics who make a living from reviewing; but like the society of which it is one minuscule part, criticism has largely become a winner-take-all profession. Those who wonder what happened to criticism should wonder what happened to the economics of it.

Posted in Economics, Links, What's Wrong with Rock Criticism? | 10 Comments »

How the Drum Machine Changed Pop Music

Posted by s woods on November 21, 2011

Enjoyed William Weir’s perspective on There’s a Riot Goin’ On (in Slate), specifically in regards to how critical the employment of (newly emerging) automated rhythm tracks were to that album’s overall aesthetic.

Groundbreaking though it was, the drum machine’s emergence in the early 1970s didn’t make a lot of waves — largely because listeners didn’t know what they were hearing. To modern ears, these early machines sound crude; it’s hard to believe anyone could mistake them with flesh-and-blood drumming. But as JJ Cale told Mojo magazine: “The deal is, in those days people didn’t know about it, so they didn’t realize what it was.”

Why is every thing ultimately at its most interesting before it becomes a “thing”? (cf. McLuhan’s idea of “effects preceding causes.”)

Posted in Links | 2 Comments »

Susan Whitall interview (part 2)

Posted by s woods on October 26, 2011

Part 2 of the Susan Whitall interview by Paula Yoo at Music Monday

Yes things have gotten better for female journalists, because of the changes in the broader culture. When I got out of college, in the mid-’70s mind you, scratching to get an ad writing job at an ad agency, the guy hiring actually said these words: ‘We start all our girls in the secretarial pool.’ I mean, right out of ‘Mad Men’!

Luckily I didn’t do that, but found Creem and caught on there. And fortunately, some of our male editors early on — Dave Marsh and Lester Bangs, particularly — were staunch feminists. Today there also isn’t the ever-present fear we had, of being mistaken for groupies. Today I think young women feel free enough, that it’s not a problem if they were taken for party girls. But we were very conscious of wanting to be seen as professionals, not girls looking for a good time. Thus when romantic liasons happened, it was pretty much kept on the down low (laugh)

(Link to part 1)

Posted in Interviews, Links | Leave a Comment »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 59 other followers