rockcritics.com

Archive for the ‘Xgau’ Category

Genesis vs. The Dean

Posted by s woods on July 28, 2011

Ward-bait!

Christgau has at Genesis; Genesis fans have back at Christgau.

I know, har-har yeah-whatever, tell-me-something-I-don’t-already-know (er, you do know where you are now, right?) but it’s funny reading this in light of a comment I posted on the architecture site recently by pre-Yo La Tengo rock critic, Ira Kaplan (from a great review, actually, of the first Christgau guide; someone mailed me a photocopy of it years ago, though the publication and date were missing… anyone know what ‘zine it’s from?).

Posted in Xgau | 8 Comments »

Christgau, Marsh, Rockwell Make New York Magazine’s Hot 100 List!

Posted by s woods on July 21, 2011

Back on March 26, 1979, I mean.

Posted in Archival, Dave Marsh, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

The Grad School of Rock

Posted by s woods on July 17, 2011

Excellent Christgau interview/profile by David Cohen at The New Zealand Listener.

“Greil, Dave [Marsh] and I were at one time very good friends, but Dave and I are no longer friends at all,” recalls Christgau. “We shared political assumptions and were all a part of the counter-culture, even though we all were extremely sceptical about drugs and the religious strain of hippiedom, which in fact was the dominant strain.

“But even back then we had serious political differences. And, as you know, it’s the curse of the minority-left to be sectarian. Our musical tastes were completely different, too. These days I would call Dave a cultural conservative, and Greil has become a person with, ah, extremely intense and narrow interests: he loves what he loves and ignores almost everything else.”

(Update: I thought this was a new interview… it’s not, I’ve just never seen it before.)

Posted in Dave Marsh, Greil Marcus, Interviews, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

Consumed Guide

Posted by s woods on July 15, 2011

Brian Joseph Davis’s Consumed Guide is described as “seven-thousand negative words assembled from 13,090 reviews by Robert Christgau.” Available on PDF, also with a Twitter feed.

Posted in Tech & Leisure, Tweets, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

“Music Criticism as Intellectualizing an Art Form”

Posted by s woods on July 7, 2011

By Bort Valentine, Cultural Critic

[Pitchfork]‘s presence in the pop culture zeitgeist (at least as far as I have experienced it) is entirely disproportionate to its readership: Alexa.com claims its US traffic rank to be 94,213th. By comparison, Blender is 8,348th, Spin is 3,832nd and Rolling Stone is 698th… even Robert Christgau’s website is more often visited…”

Well, I’m grateful to have been pointed towards the Alexa website, which I’d never heard of before, but regarding the popularity of Christgau’s site vs. Pitchfork‘s, the data is totally bonkers, at least judging by my search. Christgau’s U.S. traffic ranking (according to Alexa) is 91,770; Pitchfork‘s U.S. traffic ranking is 907 (yeah, my eyes popped out of my head also) (Rolling Stone is 643; Google is #1; Huffington Post is #24). No idea how reliable any of this is, but these numbers, at least in relation to one another, don’t feel wrong. (Rockcritics.com currently ranks 9,190,864th.)

Posted in Links, Xgau | 1 Comment »

“For David”

Posted by s woods on July 7, 2011

Inleaf from my used paperback version of Christgau’s Any Old Way You Choose It. No clue who David is, but my guess is that he grew into a well-adjusted individual (with Christgau and a cool mom as his intellectual/spiritual guides, how couldn’t he?).

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Scott's Bookshelf, Xgau | 2 Comments »

Reading Books About Hüsker Dü

Posted by s woods on June 25, 2011

Hüsker Dü’s Propulsive Liberation (Reviews of two new Dü books by Christgaü — including one co-written by Mould and Michael Azerrad — in the New York Times)

“Three dec­ades later I still feel lucky to have experienced that transmutation of wrath into flight. Not only did Hüsker Dü generate an impressive recorded legacy during their eight years on earth, they were ferocious live — as memorable onstage as Nirvana or the Rolling Stones. They deserve one great book, not these two mediocre ones.”

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Punk, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

McLuhan & Xgau

Posted by s woods on June 24, 2011

Search results for “mcluhan” at robertchristgau.com:

“What makes it even more discomforting is that our former National Pastime has become square. McLuhan and his minions in the big media have almost delegitimized it, and with reason. Baseball is an old-fashioned game. Its pace is so slow that it is now chic to claim to enjoy the gossip of the game more than the contest itself.”
- review of Jim Bouton’s Ball Four, 1971

MM in Understanding Media:
“The characteristic mode of the baseball game is that it features one-thing-at-a-time. It is a lineal, expansive game which, like golf, is perfectly adapted to the outlook of an individualist and inner-directed society. Timing and waiting are of the essence, with the entire field in suspense waiting upon the performance of a single player. By contrast, football, basketball, and ice hockey are games in which many events occur simultaneously, with the entire team involved at the same time.”

(This site has an interesting graph, based on Gallup polls, showing the relative relational popularity of football and baseball.)

——————————————————————–

2) “It is by creating a mood that asks ‘Why should this mean anything?’ that the so-called rock poets can really write poetry — poetry that not only says something, but says it as only rock music can. For once Marshall McLuhan’s terminology tells us something: rock lyrics are a cool medium. Go ahead and mumble. Drown the voices in guitars. If somebody really wants to know what you’re saying, he’ll take the trouble, and in that trouble lies your art. On a crude level this permits the kind of one-to-one symbolism of pot songs like ‘Along Comes Mary’ and ‘That Acapulco Gold.’”
- from “Rock Lyrics are Poetry (Maybe),” 1967

A nicely drawn example of the participatory (“if someone wants to know…”), un-filled-in nature of MM’s definition of “cool.”

——————————————————————–

3) “This way of explaining the children-of-affluence idea is the one instance in which Reich’s popularization elevates itself to synthesis, which is really what popularization should do. It is a concise and sane interpretation of ideas implicit in thinkers like McLuhan and Fuller. That it has received scant attention even from Reich’s fans indicates how deeply ingrained the Consumer Society cliché, which it contravenes, has become among American nay-sayers.”
- review of Charles A. Reich’s The Greening of America, 1970

I’m unfamiliar with Reich’s book or thesis, but Christgau is voicing what seems to me a fairly typical and unsurprising (though nonetheless interesting — at least if you’re a fan of McLuhan) pattern: that is, that MM’s ideas — assuming Reich is indeed re-playing them in a more “concise and sane” way — have always had a much better chance of reaching a broader audience when translated into plain/sane English. (Better still, don’t acknowledge the source at all, for the very word “McLuhan” can still induce a screeching, nails-on-a-chalkboard effect, depending on the audience.)

Posted in McLuhan @100, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

“Top Music Critic”

Posted by s woods on June 22, 2011

A gorgeous response to Christgau on Lady Gaga.

Posted in Art & Photography, Links, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

Willis and Nelson: anti-eclectics?

Posted by s woods on May 25, 2011

“[Willis] never stressed much about coverage while writing her Rock, Etc. column, and especially in her writing that followed; she tracked every move of the Who, Bob Dylan, the Stones, Janis, and the Velvet Underground as she blatantly ignored others.”
- Nona Willis Aronowitz, introduction to Out of the Vinyl Deeps: Ellen Willis on Rock Music

“‘I get so many records,’ Paul said, ‘but I go through most of them and, after one listen, that’s that. But I find a good one and it doesn’t come off the turntable for six months. I’ll play three records all year.’”
- Paul Nelson, quoted in Kevin Avery’s Everything is an Afterthought: The Life and Writings of Paul Nelson

I’m just floating these words out there, don’t really have much to say about them. I’ve been reading the two books in tandem — they’re both wonderful, though the Nelson bio, I have to say, is completely amazing, one of the half dozen greatest music books I’ve ever read, maybe — and one thing that struck me about both Willis and Nelson (and about the era in which they participated as rock critics) was their general disinterest in trying to “cover the bases.” Their frames of reference — at least within the sphere of music — were relatively tiny compared to most rock critics. (This is not to suggest that they did so as any kind of self-imposed rule, anymore than it’s to suggest that they didn’t on occasion surprise you with a left turn in their tastes. I’m talking in fairly broad terms here, of course.) It’s kind of astonishing when you think about it. One of the primary functions of rock criticism has been precisely the opposite — to cover as much stuff out there as possible. (cf. Christgau’s comment somewhere — can’t recall where exactly — something to the effect that “eclecticism is the first cliché of rock criticism”). Today, you simply couldn’t do what Nelson or Willis did. Well, you could, of course, on a blog (or in a boring specialist punk ‘zine or some such), but you’d never get paid for it, not by the New Yorker, not by Rolling Stone, or Spin, et al. You need to express (or feign) some interest in all (or anyway, most) of what’s going on. The irony being, of course, that it’s more impossible than ever to do so, given the infinite glut of genres, sub-genres, etc.

Posted in Book (P)reviews, Ellen Willis, Paul Nelson, Xgau | 1 Comment »

Robert Christgau vs. Albert Goldman vs. John Lennon vs. James Wolcott vs. ’60s rock critics vs. etc.

Posted by s woods on November 17, 2009

In this corner, Dean Christgau:

In this corner, James Wolcott:

And the winner is?

Posted in Xgau, YouTubes | 2 Comments »

Rockcritics Podcast: Chuck Eddy (Part 3)

Posted by s woods on October 29, 2008

The third (and final) installment of my chat with Mr. Eddy, regarding record guides. Here we yammer on about:

(This segment just a little under 25 minutes… Enjoy!)

Posted in Chuck Eddy, Podcast, Scott's Bookshelf, Xgau | 13 Comments »

Perfect Sound Forever’s Summer Session with The Dean of Rock Critics, Robert Christgau

Posted by A.C. Rhodes on February 25, 2008

Robert Christgau, of course otherwise known as the Dean of Rock Critics, will be editing the June 2008 edition of Perfect Sound Forever.

Needless to say, the folks there are pretty excited about the prospect of having the Dean serving as guest editor for the summer issue.

“We here at Perfect Sound Forever are very proud to be working with Robert Christgau on our June 2008 issue,” said Jason Gross, editor and main scribe. “So far, we’re mulling over the papers but I’ve been very impressed with what I’ve seen so far – this could be the next generation of music scribes.”

The Dean has been a longtime supporter of PSF, going from interview subject to contributor to editor (though, as Gross asserts, he likely won’t take the next step to become owner).

For this special issue, Christgau will select from his Princeton University class’ articles, many of which were final papers that the class submitted and cover a wide range of subjects (at this point is still being worked out). According to both Gross and Christgau, the promising young writers may turn out to be the next heralded generation of music journalists.

“Since PSF has long worked with up-and-coming wordsmiths, we’re also pleased to be giving these writers a forum and one of their first forays into the world of journalism,” adds Gross.

Yet, before that, the decision for Christgau to even take part was, according to him, very simple.

“I’ve taught a required music history and writing course for REMU, NYU’s Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, for four years, and also taught a course in cultural journalism at Princeton last fall,” the writer said by weekend email. He also shed some light into the student thought process.

“The REMU students usually don’t conceive themselves as writers, although every term one or two get the bug, and many more prove to be excellent writers once they’re shown how, with a special facility for describing music because a career in music is their life plan (and, quite often, music is their life). Most of my Princeton students were not music specialists, but I got a few good music papers there as well.

“Since some of this work taught me stuff, and much of it seemed much better than most of what I encounter online, I thought it would be cool to make the best of it available to the public, and Jason volunteered an issue of PSF for the purpose.”

But, Christgau shares that the process hasn’t been that even.

“There have been setbacks – lost manuscripts and files, students studying abroad, and in one case proprietary information that the student wasn’t supposed to use outside of an academic context. But we should have an issue, with topics ranging from pre-Stankonia OutKast and the metal band Killswitch Engage to Janet and Britney and The Hills, from the Shirelles to Cajun music. Still need to sort it out, but those are some candidates.”

Christgau graduated from Dartmouth University in 1962. While there, he explored his interests in jazz to rock. Ever the consumate east coaster, Christgau went on to writer for Playboy, Spin, aside from Creem. After teaching at the California Institute of the Arts, he became an adjunct professor in the Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music at New York University (NYU).

Likewise, among other things, Perfect Sound Forever is the longest running and one of the most entertaining and successful online music publications.

Posted in News, Xgau | 4 Comments »

Old Letters #8

Posted by s woods on February 8, 2008

[CREEM, November 1975]

Posted in Creem, Dear Ed., Xgau | Leave a Comment »

Dean’s List

Posted by s woods on February 1, 2008

Just in case anyone missed it this year…

Posted in Links, Xgau | Leave a Comment »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.