Question of the Week: Which albums are horribly…


September 1, 2009 by A.C. Rhodes

some_exile_I_never_leftoverrated or lauded as being epic?


19 thoughts on “Question of the Week: Which albums are horribly…

  1. Mark says:

    Tupac’s All Eyez on Me

  2. profe says:

    Easy: Dark Side of the Moon. It’s a great album but nowhere as good as the average, middle-aged Brit thinks it is.

  3. BobGulla says:

    OK, so I’ll be really unoriginal and say The Wall, which to me is a couple of really good songs wrapped in a bunch of bloat.

  4. Tom Lane says:

    For me it’s definitely Tricky’s Maxinquaye. I think Christgau gave it an A+. I still have a copy of it, for research purposes only.

  5. Tom Lane says:

    Oh, and hate to keep it in the 90’s, but also on the horribly overrated list: any album by Sleater-Kinney.

  6. Squally Showers says:

    The collected works of Notorious B.I.G.

  7. Bill C. says:

    Astral Weeks
    The Chronic
    Colossal Youth
    The Workingman’s Dead
    and, oh yeah… Abbey Road

  8. Chris B. says:

    I’m sure that once this decade winds down even further there’ll be a lot more lauding of Wilco’s Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, but I always thought that record sounded dull and pretentious.

  9. Nick says:

    Radiohead’s Ok Computer, Zeppelin IV. Astral Weeks- maybe over-lauded but still a great album.

  10. Thomas says:

    Anything by the Beatles, radiohead, pink floyd after barret, u2, hell almost any brit-pop.

  11. Matt says:

    On the modern side, that new Animal Collective album, whatever it’s called (Merriweather Pavillion?) that everyone’s slobbering over is cataclysmically bad.

    On the historical side, I’ll agree that pretty much any Pink Floyd album’s only mediocre at best.

  12. LM Fogel says:

    Neutral Milk Hotel “In the Aeroplane over the Sea”. I wrote a scathing pan of it on

  13. Antoine says:

    Anything by the Beatles, radiohead, pink floyd after barrwt, u2, hell almost any brit-pop.;

  14. Ben Heller says:

    “Never Mind The Bollocks” – never lived up to the hype.
    “Nevermind” – As above

  15. Fred Mills says:

    I used to be a Tubular Bells man – since it ran for 25 minutes on side one, it was perfect for sex (in my mind, “epic” sex no doubt… oof…), not to mention being a “full doob” (e.g., one could casually smoke an entire joint, sometimes two, without otherwise having to stir) platter. I just got curious about it this week reading the Mojo piece on Mike Oldfield, so I dragged the old LP out and put it on and, uh…. wow. It sucks. Talk about misspent youth. But the sex was epic!

  16. Mark Kemp says:

    60s: Beatles: Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band
    70s: Pink Floyd: The Dark Side of the Moon
    80s: Paul Simon: Graceland
    90s: Guided By Voices: Bee Thousand
    00s: The National: Boxer

    Not saying these are bad — only that the kudos were way out of proportion with the actual quality of the music and/or importance of the album.

    And I beg to differ with Tom Lane: Maxinquaye was and still is easily as good as its hype, IMO.

  17. Reya Hart says:

    Rio duran duran
    anything by Zappa.

  18. Tom says:

    The first Moby Grape album, Sgt. Pepper, Band on the Run, anything by the Libertines.

  19. Tom says:

    I should have also added There’s A Riot Goin’ On, the last three Dylan albums and a lot of the noisier side of Sonic Youth.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: