The Priests of RockThink

It has always been hard for the priests of RockThink to deal with punk in any manner other than ideological; this is why the Sex Pistols go down in history as somehow more valuable than the Buzzcocks.) An almost unlistenable triple LP dedicated to a communist revolutionary government (The Clash’s Sandinista!) means more to those who write the histories than an unspeakably gorgeous #1 pop song like [the Bee Gees’] ‘Too Much Heaven.’
Brian Doherty, Death Before Disco, Reason Magazine, 2003

[For the record, I’ll take Sandinista! over “Too Much Heaven,” but the point is nevertheless well-taken.]

sandinista bee-gees

5 thoughts on “The Priests of RockThink

  1. Well, here we go again — this is why I was looking for an Ayn Rand in the woodpile on the Rush thread the other day. “Reason” Magazine is a libertarian journal dedicated to the late Ms. Rand’s philosophy, and much more rigidly “ideological” than anything the Clash ever essayed. Thus Doherty might have a built-in bias against the Sex Pistols and Clash, since they’ve always been esteemed by most rock critics, who tend to be liberal in their politics. Personally, this lib likes the Pistols, Clash, and Buzzcocks equally, for their varied punk sounds, whatever their politics.

  2. What’s weird is, I didn’t even catch the libertarian slant–clueless me. Does shade the guy’s sentiment a tad, but I can’t say I haven’t made similar arguments through the years (re: disco/punk) regardless. As I said, I prefer Sandinista! to “Too Much Heaven.” But I also prefer “Night Fever” to Combat Rock.

    One thing I do think is dumb, though (and I feel silly for not catching this first time around), is attributing a particular ideology to the Sex Pistols. The Clash are undeniably as left as they come, but the Pistols? Hardly–the question just seems irrelevant to a group responsible for “Holidays in the Sun” and “Bodies” and “Anarchy in the UK,”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.