Tom Smucker is a major first-generation rock critic with an unusual career trajectory. By choice never a fulltime critic, he still wrote for The Village Voice, placed an essay in the seminal 1980 edition of The Rolling Stone Illustrated History of Rock and Roll, and broke through the popular vs. academic press wall by publishing a superb book on the Beach Boys in 2018. Smucker appeals to me so much because his arguments are as challenging of critical habits as his tone is friendly. He has sincerely championed the unhip and uncelebrated without ever coming off as if he were just being contrary to get attention.  Continue reading “Never Known as a Nonbeliever: Tom Smucker on Disco and The Beach Boys” →